Can flashing be fixed with roof cement or caulk?
Sealant can slow a small leak for a while, but flashing works by overlap, not by glue. A bead of sealant over failed or badly laid metal usually cracks and lets the water back in. A roofer will often replace or re-lay the metal and treat sealant as a finishing touch.
Sealants stay flexible only for so long, and a roof moves a little through every freeze and thaw. A thick smear of old roof cement along a join tells a roofer that someone chased a leak before, and it often hides the real entry point. It is also messy to work around, so removing it can be part of the repair.
A quick sealant touch-up is sometimes a reasonable stopgap for a hairline gap on sound metal until a roofer can come. Ask the roofer whether sealing makes sense on your join or whether the metal needs to come out.
Why does flashing fail first on older Rhode Island roofs?
Older roofs have more joins, and each join is a place for water to get in. Metal wears, sealant dries out, and freeze-thaw cycles work gaps open over the years. Multi-gabled houses, dormers and additions give the weather the most places to find a weak spot.
Think about what a Victorian-era house is made of: porches, bays, dormers, tall chimneys and a roofline that steps up and down. Cranston's Edgewood Historic District holds mostly homes built between 1880 and 1962, and many have this kind of complicated roof. Each change in the roof plane needs metal, and every piece is a place that can fail.
Houses that have been re-roofed several times add another wrinkle. If new shingles went over old ones, the flashing may have been left in place from an earlier layer, or tucked in at the wrong depth, and that sets up a leak that looks like a new problem.
How can I tell flashing from the shingles as the leak source?
Leaks from flashing usually show up near a join, at a wall, valley or dormer, and often only in wind-driven rain or during a thaw. A leak from worn shingles tends to appear across an open slope. A roofer traces from the stain upslope to find which one it is.
A useful clue is where and when the stain appears. A mark on the ceiling just inside the wall of a dormer, which grows in an easterly storm, points at the metal there. A stain well away from any join and in the middle of a slope points at the shingles themselves, which is a job for roof repair or, if the slope is worn out, a replacement.
Do not climb up to look. Photos from the yard with a zoom, and a note of which room the stain is in, are enough for a roofer to plan the visit.
Is salt air a factor for flashing near the bay?
It can be. Roofs on waterfront streets in Barrington, Warren, Bristol and Jamestown sit in salt air and bay wind, and some metals and fasteners hold up better there than others. It is worth asking a roofer what metal and fasteners they plan to use before you agree to the work.
Corrosion-resistant fasteners and flashing are worth asking about on any shoreline roof. A roofer who works those towns will have a view on which metals suit the exposure, and may point out that a mismatch of two different metals touching can speed corrosion.
Away from the water, the main wear on flashing is freeze and thaw, and a roof that sits under tall trees collects leaf litter in its valleys, which keeps them wet.